The gospel of Matthew is perhaps the most comprehensive of the four canonical gospels. As such it happens to include a brief but remarkable passage found in none of the other three (and in fact, it’s not found, nor even referenced, any any other New Testament book).
This is its description of “the rising of ‘the saints’ at the time of Jesus’ death. This passage gets little attention from believers — perhaps due to its brevity, but more likely due to its improbable and even shocking nature. Here it is (the salient portion is in boldface):
And Jesus cried out again with a loud voice, and yielded up His spirit. And behold, the veil of the temple was torn in two from top to bottom; and the earth shook and the rocks were split. The tombs were opened, and many bodies of the saints who had fallen asleep were raised; and coming out of the tombs after His resurrection they entered the holy city and appeared to many. (Mt 27:50-53)
This passage is unique to Matthew. It’ not found in any other Bible book, and isn’t even alluded to, in any of them. Some of the Church Fathers mention it, but it didn’t get much attention even in classical times. It gets even less attention now.
It’s safe to say that nothing of the sort actually occurred. Dead people didn’t rise from their graves in or around Jerusalem. It didn’t happen at the time Jesus died; it didn’t happen at any point in the 1st century BCE; it didn’t happen in any other place on the planet earth; and it never happened at any time, ever.
Moreover, no serious Bible scholar — aside from only the most fervent Biblical literalists — believe any such thing occurred, either. It was an absolute, total, non-event.
Other questions about this brief passage remain. They’re almost beyond count! Among them are the following considerations:
To be clear, there’s no way to meaningfully answer any of these questions. Not enough is said about this event to build on. Not to mention a total lack of independent attestation.
It’s hard to guess why the evangelist included such a truly bizarre, not to mention macabre, detail in his gospel. Aside from the question of whether or not he may have believed it actually had happened, its inclusion has typically been attributed to his wider effort to tie Jesus to prophecy. As such, this is only one of several other prophecy-related tie-ins that are found in Matthew.
While Mt 27:51-52 isn’t a direct quote of anything in Jewish scripture, it does reflect at least a few verses in what Christians now call “the Old Testament”:
Your dead will live
Their corpses will rise.
You who lie in the dust, awake and shout for joy,
For your dew is as the dew of the dawn,
And the earth will give birth to the departed spirits. (Is 26:19)
Therefore prophesy and say to them, “Thus says the Lord God, ‘Behold, I will open your graves and cause you to come up out of your graves, My people; and I will bring you into the land of Israel. Then you will know that I am the Lord, when I have opened your graves and caused you to come up out of your graves, My people’.” (Ezek 37:12-13)
Many of those who sleep in the dust of the ground will awake, these to everlasting life, but the others to disgrace and everlasting contempt. (Dan 12:2)
Mt 27:51-52 also happens to be a weaker reflection of the following Old Testament verse:
Shall I ransom them from the power of Sheol?
Shall I redeem them from death?
O Death, where are your thorns?
O Sheol, where is your sting?
Compassion will be hidden from My sight. (Hos 13:14)
The Matthew passage uses the κοινη (koinē or “common”) Greek word ‘αγιωι (hagiōi), meaning “the holy ones,” to describe those who are raised.
In the Greek translation of Jewish scripture that was available at that time — now known as the Septuagint — this word didn’t have that meaning. It never referred to anyone who’d already died. Instead, it referred to the living, to people who were blessed, righteous, or in some other way specially dedicated to YHWH.
Thus, while the evangelist may have attempted to reflect Old Testament “prophecy” and link Jesus to it, he did so in a way that didn’t exactly coincide with the texts he’d ostensibly been working from.
For this reason, some scholars question the idea that the evangelist had been trying to link Jesus to Jewish scriptural “prophecy.” Assuming he composed his gospel with a copy of the Septuagint in front of him, he’d diverged from that source — at least, in terms of the meaning of this word. In that case, in what other ways did he differ from his source material?
It turns out the answer to this question is a bit complicated. There are, to be sure, several points in the gospel where the evangelist both directly quotes Jewish scripture and explicitly states that Jesus had fulfilled prophecy:
Those are far from a full list of such incidents, but they show how the evangelist handled the concept of Jesus fulfilling Jewish scriptural prophecies. As noted, he didn’t employ this method in reference to the risen saints. Likewise, he didn’t employ it in other similar instances. For example:
Given these two fundamentally-separate approaches, scholars surmise that the evangelist worked from existing sources — one or more oral traditions, and possibly one or more written accounts. The different approaches reflected the source from which he’d obtained any given narrative element.
Some of those sources may have been less than clear as to what scriptural passage they referred to. This appears to have especially been the case for narratives that are barrages of such references and allusions (i.e. the Transfiguration and the Passion). Others may have been clearer and more explicit, so the evangelist found it possible to locate a Septuagint passage and quote it (such as he did with the “virgin birth.”)
Recalling that the evangelist didn’t have the kinds of scriptural-reference tools that would later be developed (such as indexes and concordances, not to mention computers and digitization in the 20th century), it makes apparent sense that he may not have been able to track down some quotations he might have wished to include. But, it’s hard to believe he couldn’t have recalled (for example) God “trampling down the waves of the sea” in Job (far from the longest book in the Septuagint) and located the correct passage within it. Even if he had to work down through a scroll (or two or three).
All of this makes for interesting speculation, but that’s about as far as this can be taken. It may be the case that Matthew simply hewed closely to each source he had, composing each element of his own gospel in a way that reflected those original accounts.
Steering back to the doctrinal and theological implications of this strange and brief passage, it was commented on by multiple Church Fathers. They universally accepted it as a historical event that took place — but had varying ideas about its significance. Some thought its ramifications through much further than others did.
Among those who mention it are Irenaeus, Origen, John Chrysostom, Jerome, and Augustine. Pretty much all of them commented on the brevity of this account, and even if only by implication, expressed disappointment both in how little was said of it and that no other evangelist mentioned it.
As one would expect, it was the academics on that list — i.e. Origen and Augustine and to a slightly lesser extent Jerome — who wrestled with it the most. Origen wondered who “the saints” were and worked out the spiritual consequences of this narrative. He also wondered if these saints had risen before Jesus rose.
This is an odd question for him to ask because Matthew states they’d left their tombs after Jesus’ resurrection. Although he concluded Jesus must have risen before them — as did every other Christian thinker — this shows he’d truly attempted to tease out the meaning and implications of this passage as far as one might go with it.
Both Jerome and Augustine wondered out loud if those saints had been “glorified” or permanently resurrected; or if they’d been more like Lazarus, raised from death by Jesus but they eventually died again, later on. Jerome seems to conclude they’d been “glorified” then must have ascended to heaven. Augustine more plainly stated that he didn’t know.
Aside from these mentions by some of the Church Fathers, Matthew’s account of the risen saints simply doesn’t loom large within Christian theological circles. The reason for this shouldn’t be surprising, based mainly on what’s said of it by the Church Fathers who did mention it. It’s a brief and ambiguous story, disappointingly so, leaving more questions than it can answer; and it’s also not attested anywhere else.
This account has had little attention ever since. In the western world in the 21st century, it’s a macabre tale — straight out of gothic horror — that few people have much interest in.
For many Christians, it’s actually something of an embarassment, given the reality that, had some deceased people risen from their graves and wandered around, even in the 1st Roman Empire, it’s difficult to conceive how that wouldn’t have been evidenced anywhere else. Yes, I’m well aware that literacy levels at that time and in that region were in the single-digit percentile, but we do have surviving documents left behind by Romans, Greeks, Jews, and others in the Levant, northern Egypt, etc., yet aside from Matthew not one of them even comes close to reporting anything of the sort.
This might explain the brevity and ambiguity of the passage in Matthew itself. Even the evangelist who’d penned it — likely based on an existing source he worked from — may have been uncomfortable with it, ultimately including within his gospel only as little of it as he felt was required.
English quotations from the Bible taken from the (NASB®) New American Standard Bible®, Copyright © 1960, 1971, 1977, 1995, 2020 by The Lockman Foundation.
↵ Go back up to Early Christian History menu.